How we decide
Admission: enters the Index with a ledger code.
Confirmation: holds after new evidence.
Revocation: removed when thresholds fail.
Note: Where evidence exists, we describe Cultural Weight in prose: adoption, imitation, reference, ritual use.
about the maision modern monclaire
Modern Monclaire names what endures in women’s culture. We keep the record and state the conditions that allow it to last.
We admit makers, works, and codes that meet three tests: Material, Proportion, Proof. Admissions are editorial and unsponsored. Revisions are dated and logged.
house Statement
Modern Monclaire is a house for standards. We accept work when it holds in real life.
The record lives in The Index (canon), The Art of Her (portraits and presence), and the Annual Codex you can hold.
-
Objects, portraits, and codes with daily reach.
-
Material, Proportion, Proof in real use.
-
Stewardship conditions. Not instructions.
Culture we track
Women’s culture, present and in progress. Makers, works, and codes that set or shift the standard for how women live, move, work, care, travel, and gather.
Independence &
Governance
Editorial independence
Modern Monclaire decisions are editorial and unsponsored. Funding does not influence outcomes. Partners receive credit lines. They do not select, rank, or edit entries.
Standards first
Every admission is evaluated against Material, Proportion, and Proof in real use. We also record stewardship conditions that support longevity. These are conditions, not instructions.
Conflicts
Reviewers with financial ties, employment ties, or close personal relationships recuse from the decision. Recusals are noted on the record.
Documentation and revisions
Each decision carries a ledger code and a dated note. When new evidence contradicts a threshold, we correct the record. Revisions and revocations are listed with reasons in the Revisions Archive.
Attribution and the Admission Mark
Partners may reference admitted works with the Admission Mark when the ledger code is included and use is approved. The badge is text-only. Misuse results in a public revocation of permission.
Appeals
Makers may submit counter-evidence within 90 days of a decision. A reviewer who was not part of the original decision evaluates the submission. The outcome is logged with a date and a short reason.
Privacy and rights
Image use follows written permission for the Index, the Annual, and press materials. Personal data collected for reservations or contact is used for operations and is not sold.
Underwriting
Underwriting supports production and access. It does not buy influence. Credit language is fixed: “Presented with [Partner Name]” in acknowledgments, not in decision text.
Editorial and unsponsored. Recusals recorded. Revisions dated and explained. Admission Mark use requires a ledger code and approval.
Our Methods
We accept work when it meets these tests in real use. We then record the conditions for longevity. No tutorials. No pay-to-play.
the Three Test
Material: grade, finish, stability. The matter itself must be resilient.
Proportion: scale in use. Weight, balance, and dimensions must hold in life, not only in images.
Proof: field evidence. A work shows endurance under normal use.
Stewardship Conditions
We log environment, handling thresholds, and assessment intervals that support longevity. Examples: light exposure limits, humidity ranges, load limits, inspection timing. These are conditions, not steps.
Culture we track
Women’s culture, present and in progress. Makers, works, and codes that set or shift the standard for how women live, move, work, care, travel, and gather.
Cultural Weight
We note signs that a work moves women’s lives or language:
Adoption across ages and contexts.
Imitation of forms or codes beyond the origin.
Reference in exhibitions and editorials.
Ritual use in work, caregiving, travel, or ceremony.
Cultural Weight supports the story. Material, Proportion, and Proof drive the decision.
The Modern Monclaire
Glossary
-
The lived field of women’s objects, portraits, and codes in daily life: work, care, movement, ceremony. Say it simply: what women use, do, make, and make mean.
-
Environmental and handling criteria that support longevity. Not instructions.
-
Acceptance thresholds for a form or material.
-
How a material ages with pass/fail thresholds.
-
Unique catalog ID, for example MM-INDEX-2025-OBJ-013.
-
Creators and works carrying weight with growing proof.
-
An entry accepted into the Index after meeting Material, Proportion, and Proof. A ledger code is assigned.
Say it simply: it made the list.
-
Silhouettes or practices that travel between makers and contexts.
Say it simply: patterns we pass on.
-
A previously admitted entry that continues to meet the standard after new evidence.
Say it simply: it still holds. -
Removal from the Index when thresholds fail or new evidence contradicts the standard.
Say it simply: it no longer meets the bar. -
A public release of decisions for the quarter. Admissions, confirmations, and any revocations are dated and recorded.
Say it simply: the seasonal update to the record. -
A defined period of work published as a coherent chapter. Seasons anchor the cadence of decisions and production.
Say it simply: a chapter of time for the record. -
The bound yearbook of a season’s record. Includes admissions, portraits, standards, revisions, and credits.
Say it simply: the book of the year. -
Modern Monclaire’s permanent canon of accepted entries, with ledger codes, notes, and dates.
Say it simply: the official list. -
The body of accepted works that define lasting value in women’s culture. The canon evolves through admissions and revisions.
Say it simply: what counts, kept on record.Item description -
Provenance
Documented origin and custody of a work, including edition numbers and notable holders.
Say it simply: where it came from and who held it.
